trying to match 100 year old Murray pine flooring
"Murray pine" is actually another name for cypress pine, but the problem in trying to match your existing timber is that it will have darkened with age. New cypress will probably be lighter, although sanding your existing floors might get back to a lighter colour that would be a better match to new timber. Red Baltic would blend in better than white Baltic but the grain pattern is quite different. Cypress is probably your best option.